Arguments against drug legalization and decriminalization
Oregon tried it. British Columbia tried it. Both reversed course. The evidence from the places that decriminalized drugs, and the organizations working for a better path, with sources.
Drug legalization is sold as compassion. The results in the places that tried it were more deaths, less treatment and voters demanding a reversal. The Foundation for Drug Policy Solutions assembled the record here, and the organizations and medical bodies that stand against legalization, so you can check every claim yourself.
- Oregon decriminalized all drugs in 2021: overdose deaths rose 75 percent, fewer than 1 percent of people entered treatment, and the state repealed it in 2024.
- British Columbia decriminalized in 2023 and let it lapse; Vancouver voted two to one for a crackdown in 2026.
- “Safe supply” opioids are diverted to the street, by the government’s own admission.
- Portugal never did what advocates claim; it requires treatment and still jails those who refuse.
- The people who lived through decriminalization want it reversed.
- Legalization creates addiction-for-profit industries; FDPS supports treatment, prevention and recovery instead.
Six arguments against drug legalization and decriminalization
The experiments have been run. Oregon decriminalized all drugs in 2021 and repealed it in 2024. British Columbia decriminalized in 2023 and let it lapse. Portugal, the model everyone cites, never did what American advocates say it did. Each argument links to its source.
1Oregon decriminalized drugs, and overdose deaths rose 75 percent
Overdose deaths in Oregon rose from 797 in 2020 to 1,392 in 2022, a 75 percent increase, against 18 percent nationally. Synthetic opioid deaths rose 261 percent.
Measure 110 passed in November 2020 with 58 percent of the vote. Possession of any drug became a $100 ticket that could be waived by calling a hotline, with no follow-up if the call never came. Fewer than one percent of the people ticketed entered treatment. Oregon moved to the highest past-month illicit drug use in the nation, homelessness rose 10.8 percent while it fell in neighboring states, violent crime rose 17.3 percent while it fell nationally, and the state transportation department reported “a predictable increase in drug-impaired driving crashes and related injuries and deaths.” In 2024 a bipartisan legislature repealed it. In the year after recriminalization, Oregon overdose deaths fell 26 percent.
Sources: CDC WONDER · FDPS analysis of Measure 110 · Oregon DOT · TDR on the post-repeal decline
2British Columbia tried it, then reversed itself
B.C.’s three-year decriminalization pilot began in 2023. The province asked to roll it back after sixteen months, and the exemption lapsed in January 2026 without renewal.
Open drug use in parks, hospitals and playgrounds, a thriving illicit market, and public backlash ended the experiment. In October 2026 Vancouver voters, in the city that was ground zero for decriminalization, voted 68.6 percent to ban open-air hard drug use and 68.0 percent to convert a former hospital into a secure treatment facility with involuntary beds. Dr. Kevin Sabet: “People with addiction need treatment, not a green light.”
Sources: Government of British Columbia · FDPS, May 2024 · TDR on the Vancouver plebiscite · PROSPER report (PDF)
3“Safe supply” puts government opioids on the street
British Columbia’s provincial health officer conceded in her own report that “greater exposure of the population to diverted medications could result in increased rates of opioid use disorder” and that the extent of diversion “is not known.”
Prescribed hydromorphone meant to replace street fentanyl has been resold to teenagers; one Vancouver addiction physician described 12-year-olds using diverted safe-supply hydromorphone “not knowing what it was.” A JAMA Internal Medicine evaluation found overdose deaths did not fall after the policy took effect. The provincial government rejected the health officer’s call to expand it: “this is a topic we do not agree on.”
Sources: B.C. Provincial Health Officer report (PDF) · National Post · Sabet in Newsweek
4Portugal is not the model advocates describe
Portugal still arrests people who use drugs in public and requires them to get treatment. Those who refuse treatment can go to jail. Open-air drug markets are illegal.
Portugal’s own drug czar, João Goulão, has said “there are a lot of myths around the Portuguese Model.” The country paired decriminalization with mandatory dissuasion commissions and heavy investment in treatment, and still saw illicit drug use rise from 7.8 percent in 2001 to 12.8 percent in 2022 and psychotic-disorder hospitalizations climb from 24 to 588. Oregon copied the decriminalization and skipped the rest. As Stanford’s Keith Humphreys put it, in Lisbon “robust cultural norms against it remained in place. But in San Francisco, the law was the main source of anti-intoxication norms.”
Sources: FDPS: Portugal vs. Oregon · Portugal vs. Oregon one-pager (PDF)
5Voters who lived through it want it reversed
Two years into Measure 110, 2 percent of Oregonians called it a success, 61 percent called it a failure, and 76 percent of Oregonians with personal drug experience backed recriminalizing possession.
An Emerson College poll for FDPS found 56 percent of Oregonians wanted the measure repealed outright and 64 percent wanted at least the penalties restored, with 74 percent of Black and 79 percent of Hispanic Oregonians backing partial repeal. The Oregonian’s editorial board, which had backed the measure, reversed itself. Vancouver’s 2026 plebiscite delivered the same verdict by more than two to one.
Sources: FDPS Emerson poll · August 2023 Oregon poll (PDF) · City of Vancouver results
6Legalization means commercialization, and commercialization means an addiction-for-profit industry
Every legal drug market in America, from tobacco to alcohol to marijuana, has been built by companies whose revenue depends on heavy users. The push to legalize all drugs is funded by the same playbook.
The Drug Policy Alliance bankrolled Measure 110. The marijuana industry spent more than $140 million on a single Florida ballot measure. Kratom’s trade association stopped a federal scheduling in 2016 with a lobbying campaign. Psychedelics’ best-known financier says it is “all about commercialization.” Decriminalizing a person’s possession is a question of justice; legalizing an industry’s sales is a question of who profits from addiction. FDPS rejects, in Sabet’s words, “the false dichotomy between legalization and criminalization, as well as between harm reduction and treatment.”
Sources: SAM: who funds marijuana legalization · Sabet in Newsweek, 2025 · FDPS on Measure 110’s funders
Who opposes drug legalization and decriminalization
Opposition to legalizing drugs is not a fringe position. It is the stated view of the American Medical Association on decriminalization, of Oregon’s own medical, police, prosecutor and city associations, and of the voters in the two places that tried it. These are the organizations doing the work.
A nonpartisan, science-based think and action tank for prevention, treatment and recovery, founded by Dr. Kevin Sabet and former Congressman Patrick Kennedy. Covers fentanyl, kratom and 7-OH, psychedelics, hemp THC and every drug beyond marijuana.
FDPS’s sister organization and the leading national voice against marijuana commercialization. Its page on who opposes marijuana legalization lists the medical bodies and groups on that side of the issue.
Families hurt by drugs, trained to tell their stories to legislators and the press. PAN now covers all drugs, from marijuana to kratom to psychedelics.
FDPS’s Canadian affiliate, a policy roundtable on prevention, education and recovery in British Columbia, whose research underpinned Vancouver’s 2026 plebiscite.
The AMA’s 2023 overdose epidemic report did not recommend decriminalizing drug possession. The Oregon Medical Association did not support Measure 110, and former Gov. John Kitzhaber, a physician, opposed it.
The League of Oregon Cities, Oregon Association Chiefs of Police, Oregon District Attorneys Association and Oregon State Sheriffs’ Association jointly called for recriminalizing possession in December 2023. The legislature agreed within three months.
The state’s recovery advocacy coalition. Its director, Mike Marshall, said Measure 110 “was never designed to promote access to treatment.”
What FDPS supports instead
Opposing legalization is not a call for mass incarceration. FDPS’s Blueprint for Effective Drug Policy, built with nearly 100 contributors across five pillars, rejects both extremes.
Deflection, diversion and drug courts as the primary approach for people with substance use disorder. Drug courts graduated 59.7 percent of participants in 2019 against a 42.6 percent national treatment completion rate.
Distinguish traffickers from users. Punishments should be genuine, certain and calibrated.
Naloxone and other evidence-based tools, always connected to a path into treatment and never as a standalone program or a substitute for it.
A national youth prevention campaign, and rapid access to quality treatment and meaningful pathways to recovery.
Read the Blueprint for Effective Drug Policy · Arguments against marijuana legalization (SAM) · Arguments against psychedelic legalization · Is kratom dangerous?
Questions people ask
What are the main arguments against drug legalization?
Where it has been tried, overdose deaths rose, treatment did not follow, public disorder grew and voters reversed it: Oregon’s overdose deaths rose 75 percent under Measure 110 and fell 26 percent after repeal; British Columbia let its decriminalization lapse; Vancouver voted two to one for a crackdown. Legalization also builds commercial industries whose profits depend on heavy use. Each argument on this page links to its source.
Did decriminalization work in Oregon?
No. Fewer than one percent of people ticketed under Measure 110 entered treatment, overdose deaths rose 75 percent in two years against 18 percent nationally, homelessness and violent crime rose while they fell elsewhere, and two years in only 2 percent of Oregonians called it a success. A bipartisan legislature repealed it in 2024, and overdose deaths fell 26 percent in the following year.
Did Portugal legalize drugs?
No. Portugal decriminalized personal possession in 2001 but still arrests people who use in public, refers them to mandatory dissuasion commissions, requires treatment and can jail those who refuse. Open-air drug markets are illegal. Its own drug czar says there are “a lot of myths around the Portuguese Model.”
Is opposing legalization the same as supporting the war on drugs?
No. FDPS supports alternatives to incarceration for people who use, including deflection, diversion and drug courts, while opposing legal commercial sales and the dismantling of consequences for trafficking. The Blueprint rejects what Sabet calls “the false dichotomy between legalization and criminalization.”
Which organizations oppose drug legalization?
FDPS, SAM, the Parent Action Network and PROSPER Canada nationally and in Canada; the American Medical Association, which did not recommend decriminalization in its overdose report; and in Oregon the medical association, the police chiefs, district attorneys, sheriffs and League of Cities, and the recovery coalition Oregon Recovers, all of which backed repeal of Measure 110.
What does FDPS support?
Prevention, treatment and recovery: a national youth prevention campaign, treatment instead of jail for people who use, harm reduction tools like naloxone linked to treatment, real consequences for trafficking, and no commercial markets for addictive drugs. The full set of 16 recommendations is in the Blueprint for Effective Drug Policy.
Prevention, treatment and recovery. Not legalization.
Read the BlueprintJoin the Parent Action NetworkGet FDPS updates

